It seems appropriate that the same company that produces the SAT and AP tests also offers a way for students to use process of elimination for colleges. Collegeboard.com has a fairly comprehensive college search function that lets you select the attributes you want in a college (e.g., size, location, majors, selectivity, etc.) and see a complete list of those schools that match your chosen criteria.
So if you’re wondering, for example, which small colleges on the East Coast have fraternities, intramural lacrosse, on-campus housing, and a major in music industry management, you can search Collegeboard.com and find the 13 schools that have what you’re looking for.